Medically reviewed by Dr Sin Yong · Last reviewed · 9 min read · Jump to questions
Published 20 October 2026 · Reviewed by Dr Sin Yong

Blackheads are open comedones: a hair follicle plugged with keratin and sebum whose top is exposed to air and darkens by oxidation, not by dirt. Treatment addresses the plugging itself, with topical retinoids as the foundation, clinic extraction or a Hydrafacial to clear what is already there, and a peel for congested skin. Dr Sin Yong first checks whether the dots on your nose are blackheads at all.
Part of Skin types and life stages →
Every blackhead starts the same way. Cells lining the hair follicle are shed too fast and stick together, sebum production is high, and the mix forms a plug that blocks the follicle opening. If the opening stays closed over the plug, you see a small skin-coloured bump: a closed comedone, or whitehead. If the opening widens and the top of the plug is exposed to air, the keratin and the melanin within it oxidise and darken: an open comedone, or blackhead. The colour is chemistry, not dirt, which is the first thing to understand, because it is why washing harder changes nothing.

Comedones are the non-inflammatory stage of acne. A comedone that stays a comedone is a cosmetic concern. A comedone whose follicle wall inflames or ruptures becomes a papule, a pustule or a nodule, and that is where marks and scars come from. This is why Dr Sin Yong treats congestion early rather than waiting for it to 'clear up', and why the first visit for blackheads is also a check for the inflammatory acne that often sits beside them; the sequence is explained on acne before scars.
Blackheads cluster where sebaceous glands are densest: the nose, the chin, the forehead and the inner cheeks. In adults, hormonal shifts, heavy or occlusive products, humidity and the friction of masks all encourage them, and they are common well past the teenage years.
Most people who ask about blackheads on the nose do not have blackheads. They have sebaceous filaments, and the distinction matters because one can be treated and the other can only be managed. A sebaceous filament is the normal lining of a pore in an oily area: a thin column of sebum, keratin and bacteria that fills the follicle opening and shows as a grey, tan or pale yellow dot. Every pore on the nose has one. They are uniform in size, sit flat with the skin, and if squeezed out produce a soft thread that refills, because the gland keeps working.
| Feature | Blackhead (open comedone) | Sebaceous filament |
|---|---|---|
| Colour | Dark brown to black plug | Grey, tan or pale yellow |
| Size and pattern | Scattered, varied in size, often slightly raised | Uniform, in every pore of the nose and inner cheeks |
| Feel | A firm plug; slightly raised rim | Flat; follows the pore |
| What comes out | A hard, dark-topped plug | A soft, pale thread |
| After removal | Does not return unless a new plug forms | Refills as a matter of course |
| Approach | Retinoid, extraction, peel | Retinoid or salicylic acid to keep them small; acceptance |
A quick test: if the dots on your nose are all the same size and colour and sit in a regular grid, they are filaments. If a few stand out as darker, larger and raised, those are blackheads. Treatment aims to clear the second and make the first less visible, and no treatment makes a pore on the nose disappear. The honest expectation for nose pores is on enlarged pores treatment.
“If every dot on your nose is the same size and colour, those are not blackheads and nobody can extract them for good. I will tell you that before I sell you a facial for them.”
Dr Sin YongOn nose pores
The options people search for are not alternatives to one another; they act at different points. A retinoid stops new plugs forming. Extraction, Hydrafacial and a peel remove the plugs already there. Done without the retinoid, any of the three gives a brief clean spell and then the same congestion. Done together, the clearing treatment gives a head start and the retinoid keeps it.

Adapalene, tretinoin and related molecules normalise the way cells lining the follicle are shed, so the plug stops forming. They are the evidence-based foundation for comedonal acne in every major guideline and are prescribed or recommended after examination, with a slow introduction because early dryness and a temporary purge of forming comedones are expected; the detail is on acne treatment.
A 'blackhead extraction facial' is manual removal of comedones with a sterile extractor after the skin has been cleansed and softened with steam or a mild acid. Performed properly it removes the whole plug without rupturing the follicle. Performed with force, especially at home with fingernails, it pushes contents into the follicle wall and turns a comedone into an inflamed spot that can mark. At this practice extraction is not a stand-alone facial; it is one step inside a plan that also addresses why the plugs form.
Hydrafacial cleanses, applies a mild acid, extracts with a vortex suction tip and infuses serums in a single session. It suits congested, dull skin and maintenance between other treatments, with lower irritation than manual extraction. It is doctor-assessed here, with settings adjusted for darker skin, and it does not change the follicle's tendency to re-plug.
A salicylic acid peel is oil-soluble, so it reaches into the follicle and loosens the plug as well as exfoliating the surface, which makes it the peel most relevant to comedones. Light peels are widely used on Asian skin, with strength, preparation and sun protection chosen to avoid post-inflammatory darkening; whether a peel suits your skin, and how it compares with laser-based refinement, is discussed on the FSX Laser page.
| Option | Acts on | Suits | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Topical retinoid | New plug formation | Everyone with recurrent comedones | Takes time to work; early dryness and purging |
| Clinic extraction | Existing open comedones | A few large, stubborn blackheads | Nothing on recurrence; harmful if forced |
| Hydrafacial | Surface congestion and filaments | Dull, congested skin; maintenance | Does not change the follicle |
| Salicylic acid peel (compared; availability is confirmed at consultation) | Plugs and surface | Oily, congested skin without active irritation | Not on tanned, irritated or melasma-prone skin without care |
Pore strips pull off the oxidised top of the plug and the surface layer of filaments, which is satisfying to look at and leaves the body of the plug in the follicle to oxidise again. Used often, they irritate the skin and can enlarge the pore opening. Physical scrubs do nothing to a plug that sits inside the follicle and abrade the surface around it. Over-washing with foaming cleansers strips the barrier, and the skin answers by producing more sebum. Squeezing with the fingers compresses the follicle from the sides, and the contents go in as readily as out; a ruptured follicle wall is the start of an inflamed spot and, on the nose and cheeks, of a mark that outlasts the blackhead itself.
Dr Sin Yong examines the skin under magnification to separate blackheads from filaments, milia and sebaceous hyperplasia, grades any acne alongside, and asks about products, hormones and habits. What decides the plan is the proportion of true comedones to filaments, whether there is inflammatory acne that takes priority, skin phototype, which sets how any acid or energy is used, and whether the aim is a clearer nose or control of recurrent congestion across the face. A plan is usually a retinoid, a clearing treatment chosen from the table above, and a review; the fee follows what is chosen and is set out in writing afterwards.
Written instructions for each treatment are in the aftercare hub.
Every treatment is performed by Dr Sin Yong personally. Singapore Medical Council registered · invited to share his clinical expertise internationally for CLASSYS, DEKA, Fotona, Hironic and Ilooda.
Come with a clean face and a list of the products you use, including hair products. How consultations work.
WhatsApp Dr Sin Yong →or use the enquiry formFirst check whether they are blackheads or sebaceous filaments; uniform grey dots in every pore are filaments and can only be kept small, not removed. True blackheads are cleared by extraction, a Hydrafacial or a salicylic acid peel and kept away with a topical retinoid, which stops the follicle re-plugging. Squeezing and pore strips remove the top of the plug and irritate the skin.
Clinic extraction clears existing open comedones cleanly when the skin is prepared and the extractor is used without force, and it is useful for a few stubborn blackheads. On its own it does nothing about recurrence, so at this practice it sits inside a plan with a retinoid or salicylic acid, and the skin is examined first to confirm the dots are blackheads rather than filaments.
They remove the oxidised tip of the plug and the surface of sebaceous filaments, which looks dramatic, while the body of the plug stays in the follicle and darkens again. Used often they irritate the skin and can enlarge pore openings. A leave-on salicylic acid or a retinoid does more over time than any strip does in a moment.
Because extraction removes the plug but not the reason it formed: shedding cells that stick together and sebum that keeps flowing. Without a retinoid or salicylic acid to normalise the follicle, a new plug forms in the same pore. If the dots return quickly and look identical, they are probably sebaceous filaments, which refill as a matter of course.
Laser is not a blackhead treatment. The plug sits inside the follicle and is addressed by retinoids, extraction or acids. Where the real concern is the visible pore and surface texture around old comedones, energy-based options for pores are discussed on the enlarged pores page, with honest expectations that a pore can be refined but not closed.
No. The dark colour is keratin and melanin oxidising at the follicle opening, not dirt, and washing harder removes nothing while stripping the barrier and raising oil production. Blackheads come from the way the follicle sheds its lining and from sebum, influenced by hormones, products, humidity and friction, which is why treatment targets the follicle rather than the surface.
Guidelines of care for the management of acne vulgaris. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2024. source
Guidelines of care for the management of acne vulgaris. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2016. source
Management of acne vulgaris: a review. JAMA, 2021. source
Comedo extraction. Archives of Dermatology, 1972. source
About this page: written and medically reviewed by Dr Sin Yong, MBBS (NUS), MRCS (Edinburgh) · Last reviewed 20 October 2026 · Illustrative images only, not patients · Editorial policy
Consultations by appointment at Orchard Road, Singapore.
Replies within clinic hours: Mon–Fri 10am–8pm, Sat 11am–3pm · How consultations work · Prefer not to use WhatsApp? · Treatment finder
WhatsApp +65 8023 7170 →